Local Eateries

West Islip, New York, is tucked away on Long Island’s gorgeous South Shore and offers not just breathtaking scenery but also a rich culinary scene that is frequently overlooked. While Long Island is known for having a thriving food scene, West Islip’s small restaurants are still undiscovered jewels. In this article, we go on a culinary tour of West Islip to find some of the top neighborhood restaurants that add to the neighborhood’s distinctive appeal.

Address for Hudson’s Mill – A Rustic Oasis is 559 Main Street, West Islip, New York 11795.

Hudson’s Mill, a secluded eatery on Main Street, entices guests with its rustic appeal and wonderful American fare. The restaurant is a favorite among residents because of its warm atmosphere and extensive cuisine, which includes anything from exquisite steaks to fresh seafood. The restaurant’s famous Hudson’s Burger, a juicy masterpiece that demonstrates the kitchen’s dedication to using high-quality ingredients and seasonings, is a must-try.

Address for Mama’s Pizzeria & Restaurant: 451 Union Boulevard, West Islip, NY 11795

Mama’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is a place worth visiting if you’re looking for genuine Italian cuisine. The extensive selection of Italian staples available at this family-run restaurant includes scorching hot pizza, smooth pasta dishes, and flavorful calzones. Mama’s is a favorite place for both everyday dining and special occasions because of the welcoming atmosphere and hearty fare.

A Sweet Escape: Samantha’s Little Piece of Heaven
600 Montauk Highway, West Islip, New York 11795

Residents of West Islip have fallen in love with Samantha’s Li’l Bit of Heaven, a charming bakery and café, thanks to its delectable desserts. Every item at Samantha’s is expertly made, from light pastries to rich desserts. Without indulging on one of their famous red velvet cupcakes, which are a local favorite, a trip here would be incomplete.

Tropical flavors at Tres Palms
16 Montauk Highway, West Islip, New York 11795

Tres Palms offers a lively dining experience that whisks customers away to a tropical paradise while bringing the aromas of the Caribbean to West Islip. The menu features a variety of meals with island influences, such as jerk chicken, coconut shrimp, and light drinks. Tres Palms is the excellent location for a leisurely supper with a view because of its outside seating area that looks out over the Great South Bay.

A Blend of Traditions at The Irish Coffee Pub
Address: 131 Carleton Avenue, just outside of West Islip in East Islip, New York 11730

The Irish Coffee Pub deserves special recognition for its ongoing appeal among locals even though it isn’t exactly in West Islip. This welcoming Irish-American bar serves filling meals and has a wide range of beverages. Everyone will find something they like at this inviting restaurant, which serves everything from all-American classics like burgers and wings to traditional Irish dishes like shepherd’s pie.

Family Traditions at Russo’s Italian Restaurant is located at 9 Udall Road in West Islip, New York 11795.

Many families in West Islip have cherished annual traditions involving Russo’s Italian Restaurant. This venerable restaurant specializes in Italian comfort food, serving crowd-pleasing classics like spaghetti and meatballs and chicken parmigiana. Russo’s is the ideal location for a nice dinner with loved ones because of the welcoming, family-friendly ambiance.

Address for Bagel Factory Cafe’s Morning Bliss is 468 Udall Road in West Islip, New York 11795.

In West Islip, it’s customary to visit the Bagel Factory Cafe first thing in the morning. This café, well-known for its freshly baked bagels and variety of spreads, provides the standard New York bagel experience. You can choose from a variety of options, such as a traditional bacon, egg, and cheese bagel or a rainbow bagel with funfetti cream cheese.

Authentic Thai Cuisine at Thai Kitchen
Location: 474 Udall Road, West Islip, New York 11795

Thai Kitchen is a secret treasure for people who like unusual flavors. With its savory curries, fragrant stir-fries, and scrumptious noodles, this intimate eatery delivers the colorful flavours of Thailand to West Islip. It’s a great place for a gastronomic journey because of the attentive service and welcoming setting.

In conclusion, despite being a small town, West Islip, New York, has a world-class culinary culture. These neighborhood restaurants provide a fantastic variety of tastes and experiences that capture the rich diversity and hospitable nature of the neighborhood. So, the next time you’re in West Islip, make sure to check out these undiscovered restaurants and enjoy the distinctive flavors they have to offer.

Back to local attractions

Scroll to Top